'Just finished working my way through this thread...very helpful and lots of food for thought! An EX-L or Touring is in our near future, and I'm deciding on an alternative to the OEM Contis which I don't believe are a good choice for my driving needs. I'm inclined to stay with the stock 20" wheels for now and decide later whether the issues some experience with those are enough to justify switching to 17 or 18" wheels and the tire options those open up. If I've understood this thread correctly, something in 265/50/R20 size would be the safe bet if sticking with the stock rims?
About half the driving of this PP will be pavement, the other half a mix of rural/rocky gravel roads with marginal upkeep, and off-road 2-tracks with sandy/silty soil. We definitely have a snow season, and when it accumulates, it's usually a mix of wet/heavy snow and the muddy/sandy soil/gravel underneath. This mis definitely cakes up around tires, so good advice from those of you cautioning to account for enough space around the tire to not get too caked up in there. Most of the rural roads are sandy/silty and fairly "liquid" when wet/snowed up; a few are the clay-dominant "gumbo" variety where things really get sticky. Bottom-line we definitely want a snowflake/severe snow rated tire, but also one that is decent the rest of the year.
During the dry/summer season, the biggest traction/control issue is the dry gravel roads where it's easy to slide a bit or get pulled into the ruts of larger vehicles, particularly with inclines/declines/twists of our minimal maintenance rural roads.
Anything that is comparatively more puncture-resistant would also be great--eventually might be a reason to go the 17/18" route to be able to run a higher ply/load-rated tire. In our rural areas there are always a few "surprises" in the roads/2-tracks, from barbed wire pieces to roofing nails to rebar in old concrete, etc., so anything that limit the damage of these would be a benefit.
Some earlier posts called out Cooper Discoverer AT3 4S, Nitto Grapper or Terra, Michelin Defender LTX, Michelin Pilot Sport and recently Toyo Open Country.
Any experiences/opinions on any of these--or others available in 265/50/R20--that you think would be the best "fit" for my driving needs/conditions?
Thanks for your time/help-