Performed a search on CBs and found mostly everyone getting the OEM one. I did find one that had a "low profile" CB but I can no longer find that product on eBay.
I'm in a position of saving as many pennies as possible so I'm considering an amazon one:
Buy BRIGHTLINES Crossbars Roof Racks Replacement for 2019 2020 2021 2022 2023 Honda Passport: Cargo Bars - Amazon.com ✓ FREE DELIVERY possible on eligible purchases
www.amazon.com
There is, unfortunately, only 37 reviews but most seem positive. The same brand has more reviews on subaru CBs that still show mostly good experiences.
I'm needing to purchase a 12+ft ladder and may not fit in the cabin. Kinda wish we had the 4-runner lowering rear window...
May purchase a basket or medium enclosed storage in the future - but will likely be limited to "light" use.
Both are fine as long as it will handle what you're loading and you get the look you want. I'm a stock kinda' guy so I went with stock but they are more expensive.
I have a cheap low profile cross bar, which they don't sell anymore because it's a knock off of the Yakima bar and they threatened lawsuits.
It all depends on what you want to carry, this one works great for a ski rack but I wouldn't use it with anything heavy or that would produce a high wind load (i.e. bikes, cargo boxes, etc).
I wouldn't take the chance on saving a couple bucks over losing your load on the freeway, buy OEM, Yakima, Thule.
OEM is discounted here Bernardi Parts for about $90 more, but honestly the Amazon ones you posted are probably fine and worth the go. My guess is 100% OEM knock off, maybe even from the same factory in China. 😆